Youtube issue, (my comments to Dave Christie, Denise and Kei´s question)
First of all, sorry for the delay in answering the previous post...I was on vacation with no computer around...and as i am so "s...l...o...w" even when i do get one....!
I have considered the question you asked me, a very interesting one, and I am going to try to express my point of view (POV) about this issue. I also think that it could generate an interesting debate, and that it could help to understand the vision of the creators/coproducers/licenses of a TV series (and probably of a movie).
I imagine that your question is simpler than that, basically is "Youtube, ok or not, do not lecture us, David" But using the opportunity your question gives me, I am going to think outloud a bit about this issue...
To start with, I think we all understand that when Youtube, Emule (or any of the systems that allow the emission/distribution of media product without the explicit permission of the owners of the product,) broadcasts a movie or an episode, this means a shortcome in the direct profits of the product, which is what we commonly called piracy, and it is a huge challenge for the development of quality audiovisual products and because of that, to the future of this industry.
I am 100% against piracy...
but it is not as simple as that...
I am going to try to divide this post in four parts. My vision as a creator, my vision as a coproducer of the series and partner of Zinkia Enterteinment, the POV the licensers can have, and at the end, my conclusions (ha, ha... it is as if I were preparing a lecture)
From the POV of the creator: for a TV series like Pocoyo, Youtube is an extraordinary tool for the transmission of its ideas, after all, although Pocoyo has been sold to many countries, it is not present in every single one of them, and in some it is not shown in "open" time..Some, like Japan
Thanks to Youtube, there is a community in Japan
Personally, I like Youtube, I like it a lot. But I can also see that it could kill my job and that of many people if we become complacent...
From the POV of coproducer and partner of the company: In Zinkia, more than 40 people work devoted to the Pocoyo series, some directly like animators, musician, illustrators, technicians, and so on... and others indirectly like financers, lawyers, and even the cleaning crew... In Granada
As you can see, the economic challenge is enormous, we are talking about a year and a half of work per season (we are in the second one), not counting the time we need to get to an agreement among coproducers, broadcasters, etc, and the time needed to get to move the pilots, the development of those, as you have seen in the "genesis" etc... you get the idea, don´t you?
As an enterprise, we have the obligation to recover the investment and to generate profits to be able to finance the following seasons, our next challenges, and of course for the partners of this very risky gamble... otherwise they would decide to take their money to a bank and invest it in a zero risk product, don´t you think?
If an audiovisual product doesn´t generate enough profit, you cannot maintain the product even if it is very beautiful and very good. (I understand 'enough profit' to mean something that is proportional to the effort and entrepreneurial risk, as I said before, otherwise the investors would choose much more secure projects or a bank product).
All of this is the case with Pocoyo and for any other audiovisual product you can think of, and of course, following this train of thought, you can understand that systems like Youtube can hurt the enterprise and put the jobs of the professionals that are part of big productions in great danger.
In that sense, the issue with Emule is horrible, and, although webs like Youtube don´t yet allow professional quality broadcasting, we have no doubt that they will in the near future, and we can imagine they could then become the TV channels of the future, but without the cost of having to pay the rightfull copyright owners and producers, and that is the key issue... for a low cost product this could be a great showcase for your product, that could be financed with sponsors, but for a big production it is not feasible.
From the POV of the licensers: This is an even more curious case. Licenser is the person or company that buys the rights for a specific type of product in one or more parts of the world. They buy the rights for books, videos, games, toys, etc. Here we have two groups, the owners of licenses for tv channels and home-videos, who naturally are completely against this type of broadcasting (Youtube, Emule, etc) because it goes directly against their bussines model, and the rest of the licensers who benefit from major exposition of the product since they will then sell more merchandise thus using the piracy as another way of no-cost advertising.
Conclusion: Seeing all of this, it seems that having a few (just a few!!!) episodes from our series in those non-official circuits (that could be called pirates) is in general a positive thing, but I am saying this for our series, which has more than 100 episodes and gets more profits from merchandising than from TV licenses. For any other audiovisual product, we have to stop and think if we are benefiting or hurting them, and in 99% of the cases it is hurting, not benefiting.
In any case, having a few episodes of Pocoyo in low resolution, like in Youtube, if we put it on a scale, and if it´s not all, but a few, it could be more positive than negative, but that is not always the case with all products, as I just said. I am not encouraging you to put any more episodes in Youtube, but the ones that are there, are ok there, let's use them to get more people interested in the series.
Any opinions?


